Book Symposium

Is Our Church Analogically Balanced?

Aaron Pidel, SJ

Abstract

Aaron Pidel, SJ, evaluates the "analogical balance" of the post-Vatican II Church using Erich Przywara’s analogia entis. Applying Przywara’s metaphysical "cross-structure" to ecclesiology, Pidel explores the tension between "Old" and "New" Catholicism. He argues that while the Council maintained essential doctrines, its rhetorical shift toward an "Easter Christianity" of dialogue and security—rather than militancy and obligation—may have negatively impacted mission effectiveness in secularized cultures.

Citations

Claude Lévi-Strauss, Tristes Tropiques (Paris: Plon, 1980), 443.

Andrew Davison, Participation in God: A Study in Christian Doctrine and Metaphysics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2019), 136.

John O’Malley, The Four Cultures of the West (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 2004), 176.

Aaron Pidel, Church of the Ever Greater God: The Ecclesiology of Erich Przywara (Notre Dame, IN: University of Notre Dame Press, 2020), 75.

Aristotle, Metaphysics 9.8 (1050b22)

Bernhard Gertz, “Kreuz-Struktur: Zur theologischen Methode Erich Przywaras,” Theologie und Philosophie 45 (1970): 555–61.

Aristotle, Metaphysics 9.8 (1049b10), quoted in Przywara, Analogia Entis, 219–20.

Erich Przywara, Polarity: A German Catholic’s Interpretation of Religion, trans. A.C. Bouquet (London: Oxford University Press, 1935), 87.

Przywara, Logos: Logos—Abendland—Reich—Commercium (Düsseldorf, DE: Patmos, 1964), 84.

Erich Przywara, Kirche in Gegensätzen (Düsseldorf, DE: Patmos, 1962).

Erich Przywara, Analogia Entis: Original Structure and Universal Rhythm, ed. and trans. John Betz and David Bentley Hart (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2013).

John Betz, Christ, the Logos of Creation (Steubenville, OH: Emmaus Academic, 2023).

Hans Urs von Balthasar, My Work: In Retrospect (San Francisco: Ignatius, 1993), 10.

Hölderin, Fragment zum Hyperion (1794).

Imago primi saeculi Societatis Iesu (1640).

Hugo Rahner, Ignatius von Loyola als Mensch und Theologe (Freiburg, DE: Herder, 1964), 422–24.

Vatican II: Renewal within Tradition, ed. Matthew Levering and Matthew Lamb (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007).

Przywara, “Image, Likeness, Symbol, Mythos, Mysterium, Logos,” in Analogia Entis, 430–462.

Przywara develops these anthropological polarities systematically in the form of a commentary on St. Ignatius Loyola’s “Principle and Foundation” in Deus semper maior: Theologie der Exerzitien, 2 vols., 2nd ed. (Wien, AT: Herold, 1964), 1:49–68.

Acta Synodalia, II/2, 574–77.

Hermann Rauschning, The Voice of Destruction (New York: G.P. Putnam’s & Sons, 1940), 225, quoted in Bernard N. Schumacher, “The Dictatorship of Conscience,” Nova et Vetera 15, no. 2 (2017): 547–78, at 548.

Karl Rahner, The Shape of the Church to Come, trans. Edward Quinn (New York: Seabury, 1974), 25.

Erich Przywara, Mensch: Typologische Anthropologie, vol. 1 (Nürnberg: Glock und Lutz, 1959), 73.

Przywara, “Thomas von Aquin,” in Ringen der Gegenwart (Augsburg, DE: Dr. Benno-Filser, 1929), 2:906–29, at 927.

Przywara, “Die fünf Wenden: Eine Grundlegung,” in Katholische Krise, ed. Bernhard Gertz (Düsseldorf, DE: Patmos, 1968), 106–22, at 113, 119.

Charles Taylor, The Language Animal: The Full Shape of the Human Linguistic Capacity (Cambridge, MA: Belknap, 2016), 163.

“Address of His Holiness Benedict XVI to the Roman Curia,” December 22, 2005, vatican.va.

Giuseppe Alberigo, “Criteri ermeneutici per una storia del Vaticano II,” in Transizione epocale: Studi sul Concilio Vaticano II (Bologna, IT: Il Mulino, 2009), 29–45, at 36.

The Letters and Diaries of John Henry Newman, vol. 25, ed. Charles S. Dessain (London: T. Nelson, 1961), 310.

David McPherson and Charles Taylor, “Re-enchanting the World: An Interview with Charles Taylor,” Philosophy & Theology 24, no. 2 (2012): 275–94, at 290–91.

John XXIII, Gaudet Mater Ecclesia, October 11, 1962, vatican.va.

Guillaume Cuchet, Comment notre monde a cessé d’être chrétien (Paris: Seuil 2018), 90.

Henri de Lubac, “Internal Causes of the Weakening and Disappearance of the Sense of the Sacred,” in Theology in History, trans. Anne Englund Nash (San Francisco: Ignatius, 1996), 223–40, at 227–28.

Karl Rahner, “Christian Pessimism,” in Theological Investigations, vol. 22, Humane Society and the Church of Tomorrow, trans. Joseph Donceel (London: Darton, Longman and Todd, 1984), 155–62, at 158.

Heinrich Denzinger, Compendium of Creeds, Definitions and Declarations on Matters of Faith and Morals, 43rd ed., ed. Peter Hünermann, Robert Fastiggi, and Anne Englund Nash (San Francisco: Ignatius Press, 2012), no. 806: Inter creatorem et creaturam non potest tanta similitudo notari, quin inter eos maior sit dissimilitudo notanda.

John O’Malley, “Vatican II: Did Anything Happen?” Theological Studies 67 (2006): 3–33, at 29.

Joseph Komonchak, “Vatican II as ‘Event,’” Theology Digest 46, no. 4 (1999), 337–52, esp. 338–42

John McGreevy, Catholicism: A Global History from the French Revolution to Pope Francis (New York: W.W. Norton, 2022), 5–6.

Przywara, “Verklärung oder Polarität” (1924), in Katholische Krise, 9–19; Eucharistie und Arbeit (Freiburg, DE: Herder, 1917).

Stephen Bullivant, Mass Exodus: Catholic Disaffiliation in Britain and America since Vatican II (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2019), 267.

Erich Pryzwara, “Gott in uns und Gott über uns,” in Ringen der Gegenwart, 2:543–78, at 573.

John Henry Newman, Apologia Pro Vita Sua (London: Bloomsbury Academic, 2014), 98.

Yves Congar, Entretiens d’automne (Paris: Cerf, 1987), 9–12.

Joseph Komonchak, “Interpreting the ‘Event’ of Vatican II,” in The Contested Legacy of Vatican II: Lessons and Prospects, ed. Lieven Boeve, Mathijs Lamberigts, Terrence Merrigan (Leuven, BE: Peeters, 2015), 1–33.

Alfonso Pérez-Agote, Religión, politica, e identidad colectiva: Hacia una deriva analítica y abierta de la teoría sociológica, Trayectorias 7 (Madrid: Centro de Investigaciones Sociológicas, 2022), 270–72.

Ian Ker, “Newman, the Councils, and Vatican II,” Communio 28, no. 4 (Winter 2001): 708–28.

Karl Rahner, “Laudatio auf Erich Przywara,” in Gnade als Freiheit: Kleine theologische Beiträge (Freiburg, DE: Herder, 1968), 268–73, at 273.

Yves Congar, Lay People in the Church: A Study for a Theology of the Laity, trans. Donald Attwater, rev. ed. (Westminster, MD: Newman, 1965), 45.

“Corpus Christi Mysticum—Eine Bilanz,” in Katholische Krise, 123–52, at 145.

“La théologie moehlerienne de l’Unité et les théologiens pravoslaves,” in L’Église est une: Hommage a Moehler, ed. P. Chaillet (Paris: Bloud & Gay, 1939), 270–94.

Acta Synodalia Sacrosancti Concilii Oecumenici Vaticani II, 6 vols. (Vatican City: Typis polyglottis Vaticanis, 1970–78), II/1, 442–44.