Articles

How Can the Veritatis Splendor Project Succeed? Problems and Prospects

David Cloutier

Abstract

After initial success in reshaping the field of moral theology, the Veritatis Splendor project of a Christocentric moral theology focused on norms with a larger context of the universal call to holiness, has faded amidst a new decade of fierce arguments over specific moral norms. David Cloutier argues that the Veritatis Splendor project can succeed if it recognizes that revisionist accounts of moral theology are not forms of relativism, nor novel moral theories, but are more fundamentally rooted in a paradigm shift to “historical consciousness.” Cloutier suggests that the Veritatis Splendor project should not deny historical consciousness but needs to offer a better account of history rooted in God’s work as displayed in the biblical narrative.

Citations

James Bretzke, “Conscience and the Synod: An Evolving Quaestio Disputata,” Journal of Moral Theology 5, no. 2 (2016): 167–72.

Russell Hittinger, “Veritatis Splendor and the Theology of Natural Law,” in Veritatis Splendor, ed. DiNoia and Cessario, 97–128, at 112.

Jeremy Wilkins, Before Truth: Lonergan, Aquinas, and the Problem of Wisdom (The Catholic University of America Press, 2018), 39–54.

Oliver O’Donovan, Finding and Seeking: Ethics as Theology, vol. 2 (Eerdmans, 2014), 230.

Paul VI, Humanae Vitae §17, encyclical letter, July 25, 1968, vatican.va.

John Paul II, Veritatis Splendor §18, encyclical letter, August 6, 1993

William Spohn, Go and Do Likewise: Jesus and Ethics (Continuum, 1999).

Richard Gula, The Call to Holiness: Embracing a Fully Christian Life (Paulist, 2003).

Richard Gula, What Are They Saying About Moral Norms? (Paulist, 1982), 5.

Richard McCormick, “Killing the Patient,” in Considering Veritatis Splendor, ed. John Wilkins (Pilgrim, 1994), 14–20, at 17.

Charles Curran, The Catholic Moral Tradition Today (Georgetown University Press, 1999), 16.

Timothy O’Connell, Making Disciples: A Handbook of Christian Moral Formation (Crossroad, 1998).

Second Vatican Council, Optatam Totius §16, October 28, 1965, vatican.va.

James F. Keenan, “Moral Theology Today,” in Commandments of Compassion (Sheed & Ward, 1999), 127–35

David Cloutier and William C. Mattison III, introduction to New Wine, New Wineskins: A Next Generation Reflects on Key Issues in Catholic Moral Theology (Rowman & Littlefield, 2005), 1–23, at 11.

J. A. DiNoia, “Veritatis Splendor: Moral Life as Transfigured Life,” in Veritatis Splendor and the Renewal of Moral Theology, ed. J. A. DiNoia and Romanus Cessario (OSV, 1999), 1–10, at 4.

James F. Keenan, A History of Catholic Moral Theology in the 20th Century (Continuum, 2010), 133.

Richard McCormick, “Some Early Reactions to Veritatis Splendor,” in John Paul II and Moral Theology, ed. Charles Curran and Richard McCormick (Paulist, 1998), 5–34, at 26.

Timothy O’Connell, Principles for a Catholic Morality, 2nd ed. (Harper & Row, [1979] 1990).

Richard Gula, Reason Informed by Faith: Foundations of Catholic Morality (Paulist, 1989).

Aline H. Kalbian, “Where Have All the Proportionalists Gone?” The Journal of Religious Ethics 30, no. 1 (2002): 3–22, https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-9795.00096.

Todd Salzman and Michael Lawler, The Sexual Person: Toward a Renewed Anthropology (Georgetown University Press, 2008), 6–9.

Klaus Demmer, Living the Truth: A Theory of Action, trans. Brian McNeil (Georgetown University Press, 2010).

Bernard Lonergan, “The Transition from a Classicist World-View to Historical Mindedness,” in A Second Collection, ed. W. F. J. Ryan and B. J. Tyrell (Westminster, 1974), 1–9.

Oliver O’Donovan, The Disappearance of Ethics: The Gifford Lectures (Eerdmans, 2024), 113.

Robert Barron, The Strangest Way: Walking the Christian Path (Orbis Books, 2002), 30.

Oliver O’Donovan, Entering Into Rest: Ethics as Theology, vol. 3 (Eerdmans, 2017), 163–64.

Michael J. Himes, “The Human Person in Contemporary Theology: From Human Nature to Authentic Subjectivity,” in Introduction to Christian Ethics: A Reader, ed. Ronald P. Hamel and Kenneth R. Himes (Paulist, 1989), 49–62, at 54.

James F. Keenan, “Notes on Moral Theology: Moral Theology and History,” Theological Studies 62 (2001): 86–104.

Charles Curran, “Catholic Social and Sexual Teaching: A Methodological Comparison,” Theology Today 44 (1988): 425–40.

Charles Curran, “Two Traditions: Historical Consciousness Meets the Immutable,” Commonweal 123, no. 17 (1996): 11–13.

Klaus Demmer, Shaping the Moral Life: An Approach to Moral Theology (Georgetown University Press, 2000), 5.

Robert McClory, Turning Point: The Inside Story of the Papal Birth Control Commission, and How Humanae Vitae Changed the Life of Patty Crowley and the Future of the Church (Crossroad, 1995).

Charles Pinches, Theology and Action: After Theory in Christian Ethics (Eerdmans, 2002), 149.

Joseph Ratzinger, Christian Brotherhood (Sheed & Ward, [1960] 1966), 80.

Pamela M. Hall, Narrative and the Natural Law: An Interpretation of Thomistic Ethics (University of Notre Dame Press, 1994), 63.

Janet E. Smith, Why Humanae Vitae Was Right: A Reader (Ignatius, 1993).

Benedict M. Ashley, “Thomism and the Transition from the Classical World-View to Historical Mindedness,” in The Future of Thomism: The Maritain Sequence, ed. Deal W. Hudson and Dennis Moran (America Maritain Association, 1992), 109–21, at 109.

John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis §10, encyclical letter, March 4, 1979, vatican.va.

Tracey Rowland, in Benedict XVI : A Guide for the Perplexed (T&T Clark, 2010), 99–100

Georg Iggers, “Historicism,” in Dictionary of the History of Ideas: Studies of Selected Pivotal Ideas, ed. Philip Paul Wiener, 5 vols. (Scribner, 1973), 2:456–64.

Oliver O’Donovan, Self, World, and Time: Ethics as Theology, vol. 1 (Eerdmans, 2013), 11.

Sarah Shortall, Soldiers of God in a Secular World: Catholic Theology and Twentieth-Century French Politics (Harvard University Press, 2021).

Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium §§24–27, apostolic exhortation, November 24, 2013, vatican.va.

Christian Smith, What Is a Person? Rethinking Humanity, Social Life, and the Moral Good from the Person Up (University of Chicago Press, 2010), 374–75.

Mary Eberstadt, Adam and Eve after the Pill: Paradoxes of the Sexual Revolution (Ignatius, 2012).

Benedict XVI, Spe Salvi §§10–15, encyclical letter, November 30, 2007, vatican.va.

Lisa Sowle Cahill, “Reframing Catholic Ethics: Is the Person an Integral and Adequate Starting Point?” Religions 8, no. 10 (2017): 215, https://doi..org/10.3390/rel8100215.

Charles Curran, Diverse Voices in Modern US Moral Theology (Georgetown University Press, 2018), 41–43.

Herbert McCabe, What Is Ethics All About? A Re-Evaluation of Law, Love, and Language (Corpus Books, 1968), 44.

James F. Keenan, Moral Wisdom: Lessons and Texts from the Catholic Tradition, 2nd ed. (Sheed and Ward, 2010), 55

Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia, post-synodal apostolic exhortation, March 19, 2016, chap. 8

Charles Curran, ed., Conscience: Readings in Catholic Moral Theology, no. 14 (Paulist, 2004).

Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium §1, November 21, 1964, vatican.va.

Alasdair MacIntyre, “Intractable Moral Disagreements,” in Intractable Disputes About the Natural Law, ed. Lawrence S. Cunningham (University of Notre Dame Press, 2009), 1–52.

Carol Glatz, “Church Must Not Be Self-Centered, Pope Francis Told Cardinals,” Catholic Herald, March 28, 2013, https://catholicherald.co.uk/church-must-not-be-self-centred-pope-francis-told-cardinals/.

Joseph Ratzinger, “Freedom and Liberation: The Anthropological Vision of the Instruction Libertatis Conscientia,” in Church, Ecumenism, and Politics (Ignatius, [1987] 2008), 239–55, at 248–49.

Pope Francis, Evangelii Gaudium §§222–25.

Pope Francis, Amoris Laetitia §§260–62.

Jean Daniélou, “The Conception of History in the Christian Tradition,” Journal of Religion 30, no. 3 (1950): 171–79, at 177