Articles

Doxological Trinitarian Scholasticism in the Medieval Victorine-Franciscan Tradition

Boyd Taylor Coolman

Abstract

Boyd Taylor Coolman explores "doxological Trinitarian Scholasticism" within the medieval Victorine-Franciscan (V-F) tradition, spanning from Hugh of Saint Victor to St. Bonaventure. This intellectual framework identifies delight in divine glory as the governing principle of Trinitarian relations ad intra and creative activity ad extra. By synthesizing Victorine triads (power, wisdom, goodness) with Franciscan transcendentals, these thinkers present a "Marian" mode of theology where rigorous speculation culminates in lyrical praise. Ultimately, this tradition fosters a Trinitarian anthropology that structures Christian life as a doxological temple dedicated to the worship of God.

Citations

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 6.23.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.11.

Graham Ward, “Welcome & Panel 9: Modern Theology,” at “New Trinitarian Ontologies,” University of Cambridge, September 13–15, 2019, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SSJUOBsJtzo&t=52s, at 50:08.

Khaled Anatolios, Deification Through the Cross (Eerdmans, 2020).

Boyd Taylor Coolman, “The Law of Moses in the Summa Halensis: A Trinitarian Reading of the Decalogue,” in Shared Scripture, Divided Faiths, ed. Frans van Liere (Brill, 2026), Ch. 6 (forthcoming).

Hugh of St. Victor, Exposition on the Canticle of Mary, trans. Franklin T. Harkins (Brepols, 2013), 427–52, at 429.

Henri de Lubac, Corpus Mysticum (University of Notre Dame, 2007), 226.

Bonaventure, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum, prologue.4.

Hugh of St. Victor, Tribus diebus 1.2

Bonaventure, Disputed Questions on the Myster of the Trinity 1.2, conclusion, trans. Zachary Hayes (Franciscan Institute, 2000), 131.

John Duns Scotus, A Treatise on God as First Principle, trans. Allan B. Wolter (Franciscan Herald, 1966), 144.

Bonaventure, On the Reduction of the Arts to Theology 5, trans. Zachary Hayes (Franciscan Institute, 1996), 44–45.

Boyd Taylor Coolman, The Theology of Hugh of St. Victor (Cambridge University Press, 2010), 163ff.

Bonaventure, Breviloquium

Richard of St. Victor, The Twelve Patriarchs 11, trans. Grover A. Zinn (Paulist, 1979), 63.

Karl Rahner, The Trinity, trans. Joseph Donceel (Herder and Herder, 1970), 47.

Anatolios, Deification and the Cross, part 2, chap. 4, “The Mutual Glorification of the Divine Trinity.”

Justus H. Hunter, If Adam Had Not Sinned: The Reason for the Incarnation from Anselm to Scotus (The Catholic University of America Press, 2020), 214ff.

Nico Den Bok, Communicating the Most High (Brepols, 1996), 156–57.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.3.

Hugh of St. Victor, Tribus diebus 22.2 (Poirel 55–56.972–82; Feiss 87).

Bonaventure, Commentary on the Gospel of Luke

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.19.

Bonaventure, Disputed Questions on the Mystery of the Trinity 1.2, in, trans. Zachary Hayes (Franciscan Institute, 2000), 153.

Hugh of St. Victor, De tribus diebus 4.1–2 (Poirel 8–9.78–89; Feiss 63), ed. Dominici Poirel, Corpus Christianorum Continuatio Mediaevalis 177 (Brepols, 2002).

Thomas Aquinas, Lectures on the Letter to the Romans, ed. John Mortensen and Enrique Alarcón, trans. Fabian Richard Larcher (Aquinas Institute, 2012), §949.

Mary Melone, Lo Spirito Santo nel De Trinitate di Riccardo di S. Vittore (Antonianum, 2001).

Robin Landrith, “The Debt of Love in the Theology of Richard of St. Victor” (PhD diss., Boston College, 2024), 132–33.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.5.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.13.

Emmanuel Falque, Saint Bonaventure and the Entrance of God into Theology (Franciscan Institute, 2018), 112–13.

Allan Wolter, “The Unshredded Scotus: A Response to Thomas Williams,” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 77, no. 3 (2003): 315–56, at 335.

SH 3 (n. 282).

“Appropriantur Trinitati.” SH 1 (n. 88), 140.

Bonaventure, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum 6.3.2.

Russell L. Friedman, “Eustace of Arras’ Question on the Distinction of the Holy Spirit from the Son,” in Intellectual Traditions at the Medieval University (Brill, 2013), 899–930.

Boyd Taylor Coolman, “‘In whom I am well pleased’: Hugh of St. Victor’s Trinitarian Aesthetics,” Pro Ecclesia 23, no. 3 (2014): 331–54.

“Beauty in Hugh of St. Victor: The First Christian Theological Aesthetics?” in Beauty and the Good: Recovering the Tradition from Plato to Duns Scotus, ed. Alice Ramos (The Catholic University of America Press, 2020), 206–35.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.11.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.11.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.15.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 3.18.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 6.13.

Richard of St. Victor, On the Trinity, trans. Christopher Evans in Trinity and Creation: A Selection of Works of Hugh, Richard, and Adam of St. Victor, eds., Boyd Taylor Coolman and Dale Coulter (Brepols, 2010).

SH 3 (n. 227).

SH 1 (n. 88), 140.

Alexander of Hales, Summa theologiae (Summa Halensis), 4 vols. (Collegium S. Bonaventurae, 1924–48).

Breviloquium 1.6.2, trans. Dominic V. Monti (Franciscan Institute, 2005), 45–46.

Hugh of St. Victor, Tribus diebus 4.2 (Poirel 9.89; Feiss 63).

Francis of Assisi, “The Praises of God,” in Early Documents, vol. 1, The Saint, ed. Regis J. Armstrong, J.A. Wayne Hellmann, and William J. Short (New City Press, 2001), 109.

Hugh of St. Victor, Tribus diebus 1.3 (Poirel 4–5.14–32; Feiss 61–62).

Jacques Delarun, The Canticle of the Sun: Francis of Assisi Reconciled (Franciscan Institute, 2016), 54.

Bernard McGinn, “Seeing the Beauty of the Lord: Mystics on Nature as Theophany,” unpublished paper delivered at Boston College, Spring 2025, 11.

Richard of St. Victor, De Trin. 5.14.

Hugh of St. Victor, Exposition on the Canticle of Mary, VTT 4:427–52, at 429.

Hugh of St. Victor, De sacramentis Christianae fidei 1.2.12 (PL 176:211A), trans. Roy J. Deferrari (Wipf & Stock, 2007), 34.

John R. Betz, “What’s New in the New Trinitarian Ontology? A Commentary on Klaus Hemmerle’s Theses Towards a Trinitarian Ontology,” Modern Theology 39, no. 1 (January 2023): 131–58, at 147.

Klaus Hemmerle, Theses Toward a Trinitarian Ontology (Angelico Press, 2020), 52

III Sent., d. 35, a. 1, q. 1 c., Opera omnia III, p. 774a

Augustine, Confessions 1.1.

Hugh of St. Victor, De quatuor voluntatibus in Christo (PL 176:844a–b).

C. S. Lewis, The Weight of Glory and Other Addresses (MacMillan, 1949), 10.

John Duns Scotus, Ordinatio, trans. Allan B. Wolter, in “John Duns Scotus on the Primacy and Personality of Christ,” in Franciscan Christology, ed. Damian McElrath (Franciscan Institute, 1994), 147.

Jan Aertsen, Medieval Philosophy as Transcendental Thought: From Philip the Chancellor (ca. 1225) to Francisco Suárez (Brill, 2012), 13, 29.

Boyd Taylor Coolman, “The Pneumatic Finality of Goodness in the Summa Halensis,” in Saint Bonaventure: Friar, Teacher, Minister, Bishop; A Celebration of the Eighth Centenary of His Birth, ed. Timothy Johnson, Katherine Wrisley-Shelby, and Marie Kolbe Zamora (Franciscan Institute, 2021), 83–98.

Khaled Anatolios, Retrieving Nicaea: The Development and Meaning of Trinitarian Doctrine (Baker Academic, 2011), 8.

Wolfhart Pannenberg, Systematic Theology, vol. 1, trans. Geoffrey W. Bromiley (Eerdmans , 1991), 335.

Neslihan Şenocak, The Poor and the Perfect: The Rise of Learning in the Franciscan Order, 1209–1310 (Cornell University Press, 2012).

Francis of Assisi, “The Earlier Rule (The Rule Without a Papal Seal)” [Regula non bullata], chap. 23 in Early Documents, vol. 1, The Saint, 85.

William J. Short, “The Rule of the Lesser Brothers: Earlier Rule, Fragments, Later Rule, The Rule for Hermitages,” in The Writings of Francis of Assisi: Rules, Testament and Admonitions, ed. Michael W. Blastic, Jay M. Hammond, and J.A. Wayne Hellman (Franciscan Institute, 2011), 31.

Boyd Taylor Coolman, Knowledge, Love, and Ecstasy in the Theology of Thomas Gallus (Oxford University Press, 2017), 215ff.

Augustine, On Christian Doctrine 1.17.16.

Achard of St. Victor (d. 1170), sermon “For the Dedication of a Church,” in Achard of St. Victor: Works, trans. and ed. Hugh Feiss (Cistercian, 2001), 242.

pseudo-Hugh of St. Victor, Lament (PL 175)

Frederick Christian Bauerschmidt, “Incarnation, Redemption, and the Character of God,” Nova et Vetera 3, no. 3 (2005): 459.

Frederick Christian Bauerschmidt, Thomas Aquinas: Faith, Reason, and Following Christ (Oxford University Press, 2013), 183–86.

Juniper Carol, Why Jesus Christ? Thomistic, Scotistic, and Conciliatory Perspectives (Trinity, 1987).

Hugh of St. Victor, De arrha anime 1:246.314ff., in L’œuvre de Hugues de Saint-Victor, vol. 1, De institutione novitiorum; De virtute orandi; De laude caritatis; De arrha anime, ed. and trans. H. B. Feiss, P. Sicard, D. Poirel, and H. Rochais (Brepols, 1997).

Boyd Taylor Coolman, “A Cord of Three Strands Is Not Easily Broken: The Transcendental Brocade of Unity, Truth, and Goodness in the Early Franciscan Intellectual Tradition,” Nova et Vetera 16 (2018): 555–80.

Justin Shaun Coyle, The Beauty of the Trinity: A Reading of the Summa Halensis (Fordham University Press, 2023), 133.

Norman Kretzmann, “Trinity and Transcendentals,” in Trinity, Incarnation, and Atonement: Philosophical and Theological Essays, ed. Ronald J. Feenstra and Cornelius Plantinga Jr. (University of Notre Dame Press, 1990), 91.