Articles

The Age of the Spirit: A Hesychast Theology of History

Tikhon Alexander Pino

Abstract

Tikhon Alexander Pino build upon John Meyendorff’s reading of Gregory Palamas to examine a hesychast theology as a ‘theology of history.’ Specifically, Pino draws attention to the way that a theology of history underpins the uniquely Palamite connections between the incarnation, on the one hand, and more abstract metaphysical categories like grace, energeia, and pneumatology, on the other.

Citations

John Meyendorff, Introduction a l’étude de Grégoire Palamas (Seuil, 1959), 257–78.

John Meyendorff, A Study of Gregory Palamas, 2nd edition (The Faith, 1974), 185–201.

Apodictic Treatises 2.76 (PS 1:147.25).

Gregory Palamas, Apodictic Treatises 1.29 (PS 1:57.2–5)

Gregory Palamas, Confession of Faith 3 (ed. Nikolaos Matsoukas, PS 2:496.10–13).

John Chrysostom, Homilies on John 29.2 (PG 59:169).

Gregory Nazianzen, Oratio 31.26, ed. Paul Gallay and Maurice Jourjon, Grégoire de Nazianze: Discours 27–31(Discours Théologiques), SC 250 (Cerf, 1978), 326.4–5.

Against Akindynos 5.15.60 (PS 3:332.8–10).

Maximos the Confessor, Ambigua 21, in On Difficulties in the Church Fathers: The “Ambigua,” ed. Nicholas Constas, vol. 1, Dumbarton Oaks Medieval Library 28 (Harvard University Press, 2014), 442–45.

Philotheos Kokkinos, Encomium 51, ed. Demetrios G. Tsames, Φιλοθέου Κωνσταντινουπόλεως τοῦ Κοκκίνου Ἁγιολογικὰ ἔργα, A´ (Center for Byzantine Studies, 1985), 482.1–11.

Gregory Palamas, Against Akindynos 1.7.38, 6.12.42 (PS 3:66–67, 419.11–13); Ep. to Athanasios of Kyzikos 21–30 (PS 2:432–41); Ekthesis 25 (PS 2:583.23–24).

Gregory Palamas, prologue to Hagioretic Tome (ed. Vasileios Pseftonkas, PS 2:567.1–568.12).

Grégoire Palamas: Défense des saints hésychastes, ed. John Meyendorff (Spicilegium Sacrum Lovaniense, 1959), 569.4, 641.20.

Against Akindynos 3.7.17 (PS 3:174.11–24).

Ep. to Arsenios the Studite 3–4 (ed. Nikolaos Matsoukas, PS 2:317–18).

John Chrysostom, Exposition of the Psalms 44 (PG 55:186).

John Chrysostom [Severian of Gabala], On the Spirit 6 (PG 52:821).

Against Akindynos 3.7.17 (PS 3:174.24–175.13).

Symeon of Thessalonica, Against All Heresies 25 (PG 155:132D–133B).

Dorothea Wendebourg, Geist oder Energie: Zur Frage der innergöttlichen Verankerung des christlichen Lebens in der byzantinischen Theologie (Kaiser, 1980).

Gregory Palamas, Homilies 24.6 (PS 6:278.102–3).

Athanasios of Alexandria, Against the Arians 3.40.4, ed. Kyriakos Savvidis, in Athanasius: Werke 1.1, Die dogmatischen Schriften, Lieferung 3: Oratio III contra Arianos (De Gruyter, 2000), 352.4–5.

Alexander Golitzin, “Dionysius Areopagites in the Works of St. Gregory Palamas: On the Question of a ‘Christological Corrective’ and Related Matters,” St. Vladimir’s Theological Quarterly 46, no. 2–3 (2002): 164–90.

John Romanides, “Notes on the Palamite Controversy and Related Topics,” Greek Orthodox Theological Review 6 (1960): 186–205.

Tikhon Pino, “Beyond Neo-Palamism: Interpreting the Legacy of St. Gregory Palamas,” Analogia 3, no. 2 (2017): 53–73.

Oscar Cullmann, Christ and Time: The Primitive Christian Conception of Time and History, 3rd edition (SCM, 1962), 86, 199, 208, 212, 225.

Gregory Palamas, Homilies 60.10 [Hom. 62 in the edition of Oikonomos cited by Meyendorff], ed. Vasileios Pseftonkas, in Γρηγορίου τοῦ Παλαμᾶ συγγράμματα (PS), vol. 6 (Kyromanos, 2015), 650.149–52

Gregory Palamas, Against Gregoras 4.61 (PS 4:374.5–8).

Against Akindynos 4.9.20 (PS 3:256.22–29).

Symeon of Thessalonica, Against All Heresies 31 (PG 155:156D–157A).

John Chrysostom, Homilies on John 30.2 (PG 59:174).

Philotheos Kokkinos, Encomium 134 (Tsames, 586–88).

Mihail Mitrea, “‘Hail, Glory of the Fathers!’: Patristic Sources and References in the Hagiographical Works of Philotheos Kokkinos,” in The Legacy of St. Gregory Palamas: Studies in Late Byzantine Theology and its Reception, ed. Tikhon Pino (Brepols).

Grégoire de Nazianze: Discours 38–41, ed. Claudio Moreschini, SC 358 (Cerf, 1990), 312–55.

Gregory Palamas, On Participation (PS 2:138.26–139.1).

Gregory Palamas, Against Akindynos 6.13.44–48, ed. Leonidas Kontogiannes and Vasileios Phanourgakes, PS 3 (Kyromanos, 1970), 420–23.

Tikhon Pino, Essence and Energies: Being and Naming God in St. Gregory Palamas (Routledge, 2023), 181–84.

Gregory Nazianzen, Carmina Dogmatica 32 (PG 37:512A).

Gregory Palamas, Apodictic Treatises 1.29, 2.73 (PS 1:57, 144).

Lowell Clucas, “The Triumph of Mysticism in Byzantium in the Fourteenth Century,” in Byzantine Studies in Honor of Milton V. Anastos, ed. Speros Vryonis, Byzantina kai Metabyzantina 4 (Undena, 1985), 164.

Dictionnaire du théologie Catholique 11.2 (Letouzey et Ané, 1932), 1764.

Gregory Palamas, Confession 9 (PS 2:498.9–13).

Against Akindynos 2.13.56 (PS 3:125.28–126.6).

Symeon of Thessalonica, Against All Heresies 25 (PG 155:132BD), trans. Tikhon Pino, in St. Symeon of Thessalonica: Against All Heresies, with the Discourse against the Latins and Chapters on Prayer (Patristic Nectar, 2024), 170–71.

Mark Eugenikos, Syllogistic Chapters Against the Akindynists, ed. M. Jugie, in Theologia Dogmatica Christianorum Orientalium, vol. 2 (Letouzey et Ané, 1933), 102n3.

Mark Eugenikos, Syllogistic Chapters against the Latins 4, ed. Louis Petit, in Documents relatifs au concile de Florence: Oeuvres anticonciliaires de Marc d’Éphèse, Documents VII–XXIV, Patrologia Orientalis 17.2 (Firmin-Didot, 1923), 375.11–28.

Symeon of Thessalonica, Against the Latins 4, ed. David Balfour, Ἁγίου Συμεὼν Θεσσαλονίκης 1416/1417–1429 ἔργα θεολογικά, Analecta Vlatadon 34 (Patriarchal Institute for Patristic Studies, 1981), 203.148–52 (trans. Pino, 248–49).

Against Akindynos 5.16.65 (PS 3:334.30–335.5)

Chapters 71 (Sinkewicz, 166.13–15).

Gregory Palamas, On Union and Distinction 33 (ed. Georgios Mantzaridis, PS 2:93.26–31).

Aristeides Papadakis, Crisis in Byzantium: The Filioque Controversy in the Patriarchate of Gregory II of Cyprus (1283–89) (Fordham University Press, 1983).

Jean-Claude Larchet, La vie et l’oeuvre théologique de Georges/Grégoire II de Chypre (1241–1290), patriarche de Constantinople (Cerf, 2012).

Basil Lourie, “What Was the Question? The Inter‐Byzantine Discussions about the Filioque, Nicephorus Blemmydes, and Gregory of Cyprus,” Scrinium 10 (2014): 499–506.

Ep. to Daniel of Ainos 4 (Matsoukas, PS 2:377.15).

Ep. to Athanasios of Kyzikos 7 (PS 2:416.22).

That Barlaam and Akindynos are the Ones Who Divide the Godhead 18 (ed. Georgios Mantzaridis, PS 2:277.3).

Chapters 129 (Sinkewicz, 234.13).

John of Damascus, On the Orthodox Faith 59, ed. Bonifatius Kotter, Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos II: Expositio Fidei, Patristische Texte und Studien 12 (De Gruyter, 1973), 144.9.

Gregory Palamas, Chapters 142 (Sinkewicz, 246.15).

Adversus Eunomium 4 (PG 29:689C), attributed to St. Basil the Great.

Gregory Palamas, Chapters 143 (Sinkewicz, 248.3).

Ep. to Symeon the Nomophylax 10 (ed. Nikolaos Matsoukas, PS 2:405.24–25)

Ep. to Athanasios of Kyzikos 23 (PS 2:434.12–13)

Against Akindynos 2.16.78 (PS 3:141.10–11)

Against Akindynos 5.24.97 (PS 3:361.26–27)

Against Gregoras 4.60 (PS 4:373.28–29)

Chapters 74, in The One Hundred and Fifty Chapters, ed. and trans. Robert E. Sinkewicz (Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies, 1988), 170.12

Apodictic Treatises 2.6 (PS 1:83.3–6)

Dialogue of an Orthodox with a Barlaamite 16, 48 (ed. Georgios Mantzaridis, PS 2:178.12–18, 210–11)

Theophanes 11, 16, 20, 27 (ed. Georgios Mantzaridis, PS 2:234.18–26, 240.30–242.2, 245–46, 255.5–27)

Chrysostom’s Exposition of the Psalms 44 (PG 55:186)

Apodictic Treatises 2.47, 2.79 (PS 1:121.23–24, 150.3)

Gregory Palamas, Ep. to John Gabras 10 (ed. Nikolaos Matsoukas, PS 2:337.14).

D. Glenn Butner, “Communion with God: An Energetic Defense of Gregory Palamas,” Modern Theology 32 (2015): 20–44.

Alexis Torrance, Human Perfection in Byzantine Theology: Attaining the Fullness of Christ (Oxford University Press, 2020), 176.

Pino, Essence and Energies, 86–98.

John Meyendorff, “Christ and Deified Humanity: Redemption, Deification and Ecclesiology,” in A Study of Gregory Palamas, 157–84.