Articles

Disambiguating Development in Moral Teaching: Slavery and Sex Contrasted

Aaron Pidel, SJ

Abstract

Aaron Pidel, SJ, refutes the claim that the Catholic Church’s historical development regarding slavery provides a legitimating precedent for revising its traditional sexual ethics. Drawing on the loci theologici of Melchor Cano and Joseph Ratzinger, the author highlights a fundamental disanalogy: While biblical and patristic teaching on slavery reflects an "ameliorative" trajectory sensitive to social context, its prohibition of same-sex acts is "univocal" and rooted in a context-transcendent anthropology. Ultimately, the shift toward abolition is presented as a modification of the ius gentium enabled by the rise of modern alternatives like centralized incarceration.

Citations

Loci theologici, lib. 12, cap. 3; p. 399.

Glancy, Slavery in Early Christianity, 73–85.

Christopher B. Hays and Richard B. Hays, The Widening of God’s Mercy: Sexuality Within the Biblical Story (Yale University Press, 2024), 211–13.

Brownson, The American Republic, 39.

Loci theologici, lib. 1, cap. 2; p. 2.

Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, trans. Alan Sheridan (Vintage, 1995), esp. 231–36.

Francisco de Vitoria, Comentarios 2-2.57.3.5.

Joel S. Panzer, The Popes and Slavery (Alba House, 1996), 7–11.

Annabel S. Brett, Changes of State: Nature and the Limits of the City in Early Modern Natural Law (Princeton University Press, 2011), 13.

Daniel Vaucher, Sklaverei in Norm und Praxis: Die frühchristlichen Kirchenordnungen (Georg Olms, 2017), 202–21, esp. 212–18.

Barrett H. Turner, “The Law of Nations as Developing Moral Law: Two Interpretations of ius gentium in the Thomistic Tradition,” The Thomist 84, no. 3 (2020): 339–93, at 352–53.

Ilaria Ramelli, Social Justice and the Legitimacy of Slavery: The Role of Philosophical Asceticism from Ancient Judaism to Late Antiquity (Oxford University Press, 2016), esp. 40–61, 159–71.

K. H. Rengstorf, “δοῦλος, σύνδουλος, δούλη, δουλεύω, δουλεία,” in Theological Dictionary of the New Testament, ed. G. Kittel and G. Friedrich, trans. G. W. Bromiley, 10 vols. (Eerdmans, 1964–1976), 2:261–80, at 276–77.

Kyle Harper, From Shame to Sin: The Christian Transformation of Sexual Morality in Late Antiquity (Harvard University Press, 2013), 145.

Christopher Kellerman, All Oppression Shall Cease: A History of Slavery, Abolitionism, and the Catholic Church (Orbis, 2022), 212.

De locis theologicis libri duodecim (Mathias Gastius, 1563), lib. 1, cap. 3; p. 4.

Gervase Corcoran, Saint Augustine on Slavery (Institutum Patristicum Augustinianum, 1985), 25.

John T. Noonan Jr., A Church that Can and Cannot Change: The Development of Catholic Moral Teaching (University of Notre Dame Press, 2005; reprint 2020), 118, 178–90.

H. Ringgren, U. Rüterswörden, H. Simian-Yofre, “‘עָבֵד ‘aḇaḏ; עֶבֶד ‘eḇeḏ; עֲבֹדָה ‘aḇōḏâ,” in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, ed. G. J. Botterweck, H. Ringgren, and H.-J. Fabry, trans. J. T. Willis, G. W. Bromiley, and D. E. Green, 16 vols. (Eerdmans, 1974–2018), 10:376–405, at 387.

Matthew Thiessen, A Jewish Paul: The Messiah’s Herald to the Gentiles (Baker Academic, 2023), 64–65.

John Boswell, Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality: Gay People in Western Europe from the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century (University of Chicago Press, 1980).

The City of God XI–XXII, trans. William Babcock (New City, 2013), 372.

Robert A. Di Vito, “Questions about the Construction of (Homo)sexuality: Same-Sex Relations in the Hebrew Bible,” in Sexual Diversity and Catholicism: Toward the Development of Moral Theology, ed. Patricia Beattie Jung and Joseph Andrew Coray (Liturgical, 2001), 108–32, at 120–21.

Christopher R. Seitz, Word Without End: The Old Testament as Abiding Theological Witness (Baker Academic, 1998), 329–334.

Katharina Pultar, “‘Sklaven von Natur aus’? Die servitus bei Thomas von Aquin,” in Theologie und Sklaverei von der Antike bis in die frühe Neuzeit, ed. Nicole Priesching and Heike Grieser (Georg Olms, 2016), 91–132.

Richard Hays, The Moral Vision of the New Testament: A Contemporary Introduction to New Testament Ethics (Harper, 1996), 382.

Avery Dulles, “Development or Reversal?,” review of A Church that Can and Cannot Change: The Development of Catholic Moral Teaching, by John T. Noonan Jr., First Things (October 2005): 53–61, at 53.

James P. Hanigan, Homosexuality: The Test Case for Christian Sexual Ethics (Paulist, 1988), 39.

Karl Rahner, “Kritische Bemerkungen zu B. J. Lonergan’s Aufsatz ‘Functional Specialties in Theology,’” in Karl Rahner Sammelte Werke, vol. 22/1a (Herder, 2013), 336–38, at 338.

Toni Alimi, Slaves of God: Augustine and Other Romans on Religion and Politics (Princeton University Press, 2024), 21–22.

Bruce J. Malina, “The New Testament and Homosexuality?,” in Jung and Coray, Sexual Diversity and Catholicism, 150–74, at 152–57.

Auustine, Letters 100–155, trans. Roland Teske (New City, 2003), 398.

Max Weber, Selections in Translation, ed. W. G. Runciman, trans. Eric Matthews (Cambridge University Press, 1978), 23–25.

Nicole Priesching, “Die Verurteilung der Sklaverei unter Gregor XVI. im Jahr 1839. Ein Traditionsbruch?,” In Supremo 59, no. 1 (2008): 143–62.

Bernhard Körner, Melchior Cano, De locis theologicis: Ein Beitrag zur theologischen Erkenntnislehre (Ulrich Moser, 1994), 72–73.

Bernhard Knorn, Theologie in Umbrüchen: Jesuitenscholastik des 16. Jahrhunderts im Dienst der Reform (Aschendorff, 2023), 96.

Luis de Molina, De iustitia et iure (Balthasar Lippius, 1602), tract. 2, disp. 106; col. 436A.

Julia O’Connell Davidson, Modern Slavery: The Margins of Freedom (Palgrave Macmillan, 2015), 162–63.

Jennifer A. Glancy, Slavery in Early Christianity (Oxford University Press, 2002), 58–59.

Harper, Slavery in the Late Roman World, AD 275–425 (Cambridge University Press, 2011), 281–325.

Orestes Brownson, The American Republic (O’Shea, 1866), 38.

Servais Pinckaers, “A Historical Perspective on Intrinsically Evil Acts,” in Renewing Thomistic Moral Theology, ed. John Berkman and Craig Steven Titus (The Catholic University of America Press, 2005), 185–235.

Pius Onyemechi Adiele, The Popes, the Catholic Church and the Transatlantic Enslavement of Black Americans 1418–1839, Sklaverei Knechtschaft Zwangsarbeit 16 (Georg Olms, 2017), 263–88.

Joshua Dubler and Vincent W. Lloyd, Break Every Yoke: Religion, Justice, and the Abolition of Prisons (Oxford University Press, 2020), 9.

Patrick W. Carey, “Orestes Brownson and the Civil War,” U.S. Catholic Historian 31, no. 1 (2013): 1–20.

Thomas Pfau, Minding the Modern (University of Notre Dame Press, 2013), 378–92.

H. Ringgren, “‘עָבֵד ‘aḇaḏ,” in Theological Dictionary of the Old Testament, 389.

Barret Turner, “Pope Francis and the Death Penalty: A Conditional Advance of Justice in the Law of Nations,” Nova et Vetera 16, no. 4 (2018): 1041–50.

Luis-Carlos Amezúa Amezúa, “La Cláusula Suareciana sobre la Esclavitud de los Negros,” Pensamiento 74, no. 279 (2018): 237–61, at 248–49, 251.

Jacob Abolafia, The Prison Before the Panopticon: Incarceration in Ancient and Modern Political Philosophy (Harvard University Press, 2024), 7, 10, 166n4.

Noel Lenski, “Violence and the Roman Slave,” in The Topography of Violence in the Greco-Roman World, ed. Gareth G. Fagan and Werner Reiss (University of Michigan Press, 2016), 275–98, at 275.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church §2267.

J. Albert Harill, Slavery in the New Testament: Literary, Social, and Moral Dimensions (Fortress, 2006), 119–44, esp. 142.

Martin Dibelius and Hans Conzelmann, A Commentary on the Pastoral Epistles, 4th rev. ed., trans. Philip Buttolph and Adela Yarbro (Fortress, 1972), 23.

Luke Timothy Johnson, The First and Second Letters of Timothy: A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary, Anchor Bible 35A (Doubleday, 2001), 170.

David Ritchie, Natural Rights: A Criticism of Some Ethical and Political Conceptions (Swan Sonnenschein, 1895), 104.

Nigel Biggar, Colonialism: A Moral Reckoning (HarperCollins, 2021), 47.

Edgardo Rotman, “The Failure of Reform: United States, 1865–1965,” in The Oxford History of the Prison, ed. Norval Morris and David J. Rothman (Oxford University Press, 1995), 151–77.

John Paul II, Veritatis Splendor §80, encyclical letter, August 6, 1993, vatican.va.

John Paul II, Evangelium Vitae §3, encyclical letter, March 25, 1995, vatican.va.

Joseph Ratzinger, “Farewell to the Devil?,” in Dogma and Preaching, 4th ed. (Ignatius, 2011), 197–206.

Bernhard Körner, Orte des Glaubens—loci theologici: Studien zur theologischen Erkenntnislehre (Echter, 2014).

Aaron Pidel, The Inspiration and Truth of Scripture: Testing the Ratzinger Paradigm (The Catholic University of America Press, 2023), 101–44.

Associated Press, “California voters reject measure that would have banned forced prison labor” (November 11, 2024), https://apnews.com/article/california-labor-prison-slavery-prop-6-election-e295b561651940e2b527d7f5128b1b53.

Newman to T. W. Allies, November 8, 1863, in The Letters and Diaries of John Henry Newman (hereafter LD), vol. 20 Standing Firm Amid Trials: July 1861–December 1863, ed. Charles Stephen Dessain (Oxford, 1972), 554–55.

Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith, Dignitas Infinita §34, declaration, March 25, 2024, vatican.va.

Denzinger: Compendium of Creeds, Definitions, and Declarations on Matters of Faith and Morals, 43rd ed., ed. Peter Hünermann (Ignatius, 2012), no. 1165, 1230; p. 322, 330.

James Muldoon, Popes, Lawyers, and Infidels (University of Pennsylvania Press, 1979), 119.

Annalisa Marzano, “Ergasterion, ergastulum,” in The Encyclopedia of Ancient History, ed. Andrew Erskine, David B. Hollander, and Arietta Papaconstantinou (John Wiley & Sons, 2021), https://doi.org/10.1002/9781444338386.wbeah06128.pub2.

Ernest H. Kantorowicz, The King’s Two Bodies: A Study in Medieval Political Theology (Princeton University Press, 1997), 5.

Sarah Shortall, “From the Three Bodies of Christ to the King’s Two Bodies: The Theological Origins of Secularization Theory,” Modern Intellectual History 20 (2023): 785–807.

“Pope Francis tells 60 Minutes in rare interview: ‘the globalization of indifference is a very ugly disease,’” May 19, 2024, accessed November 22, 2024, https://www.cbsnews.com/news/pope-francis-interview-60-minutes-transcript/.

Francis, The Strength of a Vocation: Consecrated Life Today (United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, 2018), 60.